Iran International
Iran’s government is pledging not to dip into the pockets of the central bank or print more money to balance its budget, but skeptics doubt there are any magic solutions to lack of income.
Iran’s budget deficit in the current fiscal year is 40-50 percent or around 5,000 trillion rials. If we convert the devalued rial amount to the highly appreciated dollar, it is around $20 billion. This would be a manageable amount if Iran could export 1.5 million barrels of crude oil daily, but currently it sells a few hundred thousand barrels at discounted prices.
According to estimates published by the parliament’s research center, only 15-20 percent of the projected oil revenues have been realized. The projection in the budget was to export 1.5 million barrels a day, which certainly was a gross overestimation, as US sanctions remained in place.
President Ebrahim Raisi’s ‘revolutionary’ government took office in August with pledges of solving the economic crisis, with his hardline supporters blaming the former administration for ineptitude. But it is common knowledge in Iran that the main cause for the steep economic decline since 2018 has been US sanctions, especially on its oil exports.
Then, why are the hardliners blaming Rouhani? The ruling elite headed by Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei does not want to admit that sanctions have caused misery. If they admit that, it means they must also admit that their confrontational foreign policy has led to economic disaster.
The Raisi government is now saying that they have found ways to generate income without borrowing from the central bank or printing money – although both mean the same thing, since the central bank has no extra foreign reserves. Former president Rouhani’s administration was printing money and fueling inflation that has reached close to 50 Percent. Absent a deal with the United States it had no other choice.
But few economists outside the government believe Raisi can magically generate revenues. Maysam Radpour, a well-known analyst in Iran was quoted by local media on Tuesday as expressing surprise that the government can find additional revenues without borrowing from the central bank or printing money. He said that neither expenditures have been cut nor tax collection increased, and US sanctions remain in place. He added that the government is muddling through amid a lack of real information about its actions.
The conservative website, Alef, published an analysis on the role of both sanctions and structural problems in generating Iran’s economic crisis. The article said that lifting sanctions is necessary for dealing with economic challenges but not sufficient without structural reforms.
Iran’s economy has many structural shortcomings and there is no choice but to do a “deep and painful surgery”, Alef said. It is an economy that has survived with injecting petrodollars to keep it going temporarily and when oil sanctions hit, it has no legs to stand on. If sanctions are lifted, economic conditions will somewhat improve the article said, but on the long-run “the reality of a sick economy will again impose its harsh impact on the country and on the people.”
Javad Owji told a budget planning meeting on Sunday that because of lack of investments in the past, the country is now faced with a stark choice – invest $160 billion in its oil and gas sector or face declining output and eventually imports of fossil fuels.
Iran’s government is in the process of drafting the budget for the next Iranian year that starts on March 21, 2022, amid a serious shortfall of revenues. In the current year the budget had a 50-percent deficit or the approximate equivalent of one year's full oil export revenues. But because of US sanctions, Iran sells much less oil and has little cash income for what it can ship in illicit ways.
The oil minster cannot hope to receive any major financing from the government given the dire financial and economic conditions. In fact, Iran failed to make the needed investments to modernize exploration and production even during the years of very high oil prices from 2005-2014, when it is estimated the country netted more than $700 billion dollars in oil revenues.
The main reason for Iran falling behind is its closed political and economic system, which is not conducive to foreign investments, cooperation and technology transfers. Iran’s constant confrontation with the West and disputes over its nuclear program that had secret elements prompting alarm, left the oil industry in isolation.
The clerical regime, increasingly dependent on the will of its Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei also has a strong inward-looking and anti-Western ideology.
Mohsen Khojastepur, general director of the Iranian national oil company said last week that if investments in the gas industry are not secured Iran will become a net importer in the coming years.
Iranian officials have been warning of inadequate natural gas production that cannot keep pace with consumption this winter and have warned people of widespread blackouts.
Fararu news website in Tehran has confirmed that the natural gas crisis is the result of insufficient investments and lack of technology that only a handful of Western energy giants can provide. Just to maintain current production, Iran needs to invest up to $50 billion in its gas fields, especially in the Persian Gulf offshore South Pars reserves shared with Qatar.
It will not be easy for Iran to make up for the lost time. Even if there is an agreement in nuclear talks, US sanctions are lifted and Iran’s oil exports reach 2.5 million barrels a day, with current prices it can hope to have gross export revenues of around $65 billion annually. But lack of efficient planning and management in addition to years of sanctions have left a very big economic hole in the country, which would takes years to fill.
One more factor can also contribute to Iran becoming a net energy importer – rampant consumption because of huge energy subsidies the government provides, estimated to be around $45 billion a year. Both electricity and fossil fuels are heavily subsidized, which encourage wasteful consumption. Gasoline is now sold at around 20-40 US cents a gallon, to give an example.
This has gone on for decades and it is a risky political proposition for the government to eliminate the subsidies. When it raised prices to the current level from even a lower price two years ago, nationwide unrest broke out and security forces using military ammunition killed hundreds of protesters, destroying the last vestiges of the regime’s legitimacy.
